Are We Teaching Kids to Write All Wrong?



Learning to Write

“As you can see, individual differences in writing can be seen as early as kindergarten,” says Cynthia Puranik, affiliate professor within the College of Education & Human Development. On her pc, she pulls up writing samples from two kindergarteners who had been requested to print phrases that they know. One kid manages “hot,” whilst the second one, extremely, executes “somber, “sarcasum” [sic] and “redundant.”

Despite the achievements of the second one kid, take a look at effects display that almost all U.S. scholars combat to meet grade-level writing requirements. Puranik is operating to support kids’s efficiency at the web page. She research the early construction of writing talents and the way educators can successfully nurture just right writers. She gained $three million ultimate yr from the U.S. Department of Education’s Institute of Education Sciences to find out about a writing intervention program she evolved during which kids lend a hand train one every other. We not too long ago spoke with Puranik concerning the significance of writing and one of the best ways to lend a hand kids be informed to do it neatly.

Your analysis specializes in how small children be informed to write. How early do those talents start to broaden?

If you take into consideration how small children and tots be informed to communicate, they don’t get started talking in complete sentences and even complete phrases. They babble, they coo after which in the end you listen the phrases pop out. That’s additionally what kids do in writing. They make marks and scribbles, and the ones marks evolve in a linear series earlier than they begin to conventionally write. Children may just get started doing this as early as two years previous.

And the ones are talents that every one kids should be informed earlier than they may be able to write?

Yes, we refer to them as ideas of print. Before kids be informed to write, they want to remember that print conveys that means, that writing is symbolic, that writing (a minimum of in English) is going from left to proper. These are ideas kids have to perceive earlier than they may be able to put phrases in combination to shape sentences. Then they use marks and scribbles to put across that means. Slowly they be informed to write the letters of the alphabet, be informed letter-sound correspondences and use that wisdom to spell unmarried phrases.

Spelling additionally is going thru levels. In the start, kids spell phrases the use of best the primary letter of the phrase, so, for instance, a preschool kid may spell the phrase mattress with only a b, then later with the primary and ultimate letter of the phrase, bd. Vowels are much less salient, and so they’re tougher for small children.

Very continuously, kids can have grand concepts however they’re now not at all times in a position to translate that on paper. That’s as a result of kids want to be fluent in transcription talents earlier than they may be able to unlock sufficient cognitive sources to be in a position to put across their concepts on paper.

Learning to Read

“Teachers sometimes worry that reading will suffer if you dedicate time to writing instruction,” says Puranik. “But I’ve shown in my research that it’s not true.”

How does a greater figuring out of the way writing develops translate to higher educating strategies?

For one, studying how writing develops can without delay tell what to train and the way to train writing. Also, by means of studying extra about how those talents broaden in standard kids, we will be able to higher serve kids with disabilities. A large think about studying is motivation. Especially with kids who’ve disabilities, you will have to in finding tactics to encourage them, and writing can also be very motivational on some point as it comes from inside of. Writing leaves an enduring file. I will display you one thing I wrote and say, “I did this!”

Assessing what makes “good” writing turns out like a subjective procedure. How can lecturers successfully assessment kids’s writing?

We don’t have just right rubrics for assessing writing high quality, even for older kids. Reading is more uncomplicated: It’s transparent when kids make mistakes when studying, or once they’re studying too slowly. For writing, lecturers don’t at all times know what to assessment. Is it the quantity the kid writes? The complexity of the sentences? Whether they may be able to generate concepts as opposed to regurgitate info? I and different researchers are proceeding to refine strategies however it’s one thing that wishes much more find out about and certainly wishes to be emphasised in trainer coaching.

You’ve created an instruction way during which kids lend a hand train one every other to write. How does it paintings?

It’s known as Peer-Assisted Writing Strategies (PAWS). We have initial analysis to display that it’s efficient. There are two theories about how kids broaden writing talents. The first is known as cognitive-linguistic principle, which specializes in the abilities required to write. The 2d is grounded in social-cultural theories, and says kids learn the way to write in social context, the place their construction relies on alternatives to engage with oldsters, lecturers, buddies and others.

PAWS used to be created as an ideal steadiness of each those theories. It specializes in vital transcription talents in keeping with the cognitive-linguistic principle. And in line with social-cultural principle it contains kids operating in pairs. It’s designed for an entire study room, and every kid works with a peer. The kids take turns being a trainer and being a creator, and the trainer supplies comments to the creator. It is designed to construct one thing known as “metalinguistic awareness.”

What impressed the speculation for PAWS?

This thought got here from watching school scholars. Most individuals who write poorly, even adults, do not know they write poorly. Part is they’ve by no means been given instruction in how to write. And a part of it’s they’ve by no means been taught to take a look at their very own writing with a crucial eye. They’ve by no means evolved metalinguistic consciousness. Very continuously I listen even graduate scholars pronouncing, “Nobody’s ever told me that before. How come nobody ever pointed that out?”

My concept used to be, why now not get started development this consciousness on the very starting? You’d be shocked how just right kids are at discovering mistakes in every different’s paintings. And by means of noticing and correcting those mistakes, it brings about consciousness of their very own writing.

You discussed that even school scholars will not be gifted writers once they arrive on campus. What do take a look at ratings disclose about writing skillability on this nation?

Less the a 3rd of youngsters within the U.S. are gifted writers, in accordance to the National Assessment of Educational Progress. Most scholars aren’t writing at grade point, and in my enjoy even graduate scholars regularly have problem writing on the point this is required.

In this nation, we’ve concentrated such a lot at the method we train studying, however kids infrequently get instruction in writing. I’m speaking about easy educational writing: How to write a persuasive essay, or how to evaluate and distinction two concepts to make some degree. Most scholars will have to have those talents by the point they graduate highschool, however very continuously they don’t. It’s why companies within the U.S. spend one thing like $three billion sending their staff to remediation categories for writing.

So, being a just right reader doesn’t at all times translate to being a just right creator?

There is a few commonality between the 2, and most of the people who’re just right writers also are voracious readers. But it’s now not at all times the case. Logically you’d assume, “If I’m not a good reader, how can I be a good writer?” However, you may have somebody who’s a Pulitzer-winning poet who has dyslexia and has bother studying.

There’s additionally a little research appearing that writing has a facilitative impact on studying, that means the advantages of writing skillability go beyond to studying skillability. But the other isn’t at all times true: studying ability doesn’t at all times translate to writing ability. Writing wishes its personal instruction and follow.

Teachers now and again fear that studying will endure should you commit time to writing instruction. But I’ve proven in my analysis that it’s now not true. In one find out about, we break up a gaggle of scholars into two teams. We took one crew of youngsters out of the school room for 30 mins an afternoon, 3 days every week for writing instruction, and the others remained within the elegance. Then we when put next their writing and studying take a look at ratings earlier than and after the instruction. The youngsters who gained the writing instruction now not best had higher writing ratings however additionally they had upper studying ratings afterwards than the children who didn’t obtain the instruction.

Should lecturers cope with studying and writing in combination?

Yes; those aren’t discrete talents, but educators generally tend to deal with them as such. This is right now not only for monolingual kids but additionally for bilingual kids. Let’s take the instance of African-American kids who use dialect. There’s a mismatch between spoken language and written language amongst those kids. Oral African-American English (AAE) does now not have a written an identical. Children who talk the use of an AAE dialect are nonetheless anticipated to write the use of usual American English.

My colleagues and I confirmed in a contemporary find out about in Child Development that complete literacy (studying and writing) instruction may just lend a hand cope with racial disparities in writing. The find out about regarded on the affect of dialect, in particular AAE on writing, and we weren’t shocked to in finding that the upper a pupil’s dialect use, the poorer their writing. But if scholars had prime dialect use however had been studying at grade point, then their writing tended to be higher. So, in case of AAE-speaking scholars, it seems that that studying has a facilitative impact on writing even within the presence of heavy dialect use. Teaching studying and writing in tandem may well be a technique to bridge the space between kids’s oral language and written language.

(Interview by means of Jennifer Rainey Marquez with Cynthia Puranik.)


“Improving Kindergarten Students’ Writing Outcomes Using Peer-Assisted Strategies” by means of Cynthia S. Puranik, Yaacov Petscher, Stephanie Al Otaiba and Christopher J. Lemons, 24 April 2018, The Elementary School Journal.DOI: 10.1086/697432

“The Relation Between Dialect Density and the Codevelopment of Writing and Reading in African American Children” by means of Cynthia Puranik, Lee Branum‐Martin and Julie A. Washington, 15 October 2019, Child Development.DOI: 10.1111/cdev.13318


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here